Skip to content
Side-by-side comparison of a Clarity portfolio roadmap and a ServiceNow project schedule
Project Portfolio Management ValueOps Clarity

Clarity or ServiceNow Strategic Portfolio Management: how to choose when ServiceNow already runs IT

Ciara Turner
Ciara Turner

When an organization already runs ServiceNow for IT service management, the question comes up quickly: should portfolio management live there too? ServiceNow Strategic Portfolio Management (SPM) is the natural first look, but Clarity tends to pull ahead when portfolios extend beyond IT or programs span dozens of projects.

The short answer: Clarity is the stronger choice when portfolios include business-led work or programs roll up across many projects. ServiceNow SPM can make sense when portfolio work is mostly IT work that already runs through ServiceNow. You can also use Clarity for portfolio planning and connect it to ServiceNow.

Clarity and ServiceNow SPM at a glance

ClarityServiceNow SPM
Best fitPortfolios across IT and the businessIT-led portfolios already on ServiceNow
Portfolio planningPortfolios across any investment type, with targets and what-if scenariosPortfolio plans with scenarios, plus Strategic Planning in SPM Prime
Financial planningCost and budget plans, labor costs from timesheets, and chargebacksCost plans, budgets, and forecasts, with labor costs from time cards. Investment Funding in SPM Prime
Resource planningRole-based staffing with staffing scenariosResource plans by role or group, with soft and hard allocations
ProgramsCustom investment types and multi-level hierarchiesPrograms with sub-project rollups
Agile deliveryRally, plus Jira through ConnectALLEnterprise Agile Planning in SPM Prime, plus Jira and Azure DevOps integrations
AIVaia AI agents across your portfolio data, plus AI spend tracking with ValueOps AI TokenomicsServiceNow Otto, with capabilities that vary by SPM package
DeploymentSaaS, including a FedRAMP-authorized cloud, or on-premisesOn the ServiceNow platform, which has a FedRAMP High government cloud

How Clarity and ServiceNow SPM compare

Portfolio planning

  • Clarity: Portfolios can hold projects, ideas, and custom investment types side by side, with cost and capacity targets and what-if scenarios to compare options before you commit. Roadmaps and OKRs connect those choices to strategy.
  • ServiceNow SPM: Portfolio Planning lets portfolio managers prioritize work and compare scenarios in both SPM packages. Strategic Planning, with roadmaps plus product and value stream views, requires SPM Prime.

Financial planning

Both handle cost plans, budgets, and forecasts, with capital and operating expense tracked separately.

  • Clarity: Approved cost plans become budget plans, and a rate matrix prices labor from timesheets. Non-labor actuals come in as financial transactions, Clarity supports chargebacks, and a parent investment's cost plan can roll up its children's actuals across the hierarchy. Financial control in PPM covers how teams connect Clarity to their financial systems.
  • ServiceNow SPM: Labor costs come from approved time cards and hourly rates, and project financials roll up from sub-projects to the parent. Investment Funding requires SPM Prime.

Resource planning

  • Clarity: In the Staffing workspace, project managers request people by role and resource managers fill those requests. Staffing scenarios let you compare options before you publish a plan, and Clarity can then build a project's cost plan from those allocations.
  • ServiceNow SPM: Resource plans are built by role or group, with soft and hard allocations, and priced with labor rates.

Programs

  • Clarity: Teams that need a program view across dozens of projects use custom investment types and multi-level hierarchies, so schedules, status, and financials roll up from each project to the program. One federal team we spoke with first tried ServiceNow's project tools but couldn't get schedules and goals to roll up across programs the way they wanted, which led them to look at Clarity. Here's how to manage programs in Clarity.
  • ServiceNow SPM: Supports programs and rolls sub-project financials up to the parent.

Portfolios beyond IT

  • Clarity: Product development, capital programs, and other business-led work each get their own custom investment type, so the whole business can plan in one place.
  • ServiceNow SPM: ServiceNow positions SPM for planning across the enterprise, and business teams already working in ServiceNow can plan there. It fits most naturally where portfolio work already flows through ServiceNow, which for many organizations is IT.

Agile delivery

  • Clarity: Connects with Rally, so funding and capacity decisions stay tied to what delivery teams are actually working on. Beyond Jira: scaling Agile with Rally covers that side. Teams on Jira connect it to Clarity through ConnectALL, as in connecting Clarity and Jira.
  • ServiceNow SPM: Enterprise Agile Planning, for scaling Agile across teams, requires SPM Prime. ServiceNow also integrates with Jira and Azure DevOps.

AI

  • Clarity: Vaia, Clarity’s built-in AI, works directly with your portfolio data. Teams set up AI agents on specific workspaces and objects, such as projects, to analyze data, summarize status and roadmaps into executive-ready reports, and draw on documents you provide. Vaia runs on your organization’s own AI service, such as Azure OpenAI, and Clarity’s AI also guides teams through writing OKRs. With ValueOps AI Tokenomics, Clarity tracks AI spend against the priorities it supports, alongside the rest of the portfolio’s costs.
  • ServiceNow SPM: ServiceNow Otto summarizes project status, helps create demands, and generates stories from epics. AI agents can also monitor project tasks. Which AI capabilities you get depends on the SPM package.

Platform and deployment

  • Clarity: Runs as its own platform, as SaaS or on-premises, with a FedRAMP-authorized cloud option for government. It connects to ServiceNow, so requests and project updates can still start in ServiceNow while planning happens in Clarity.
  • ServiceNow SPM: Runs on the same platform as your service management, so demand comes in through workflows people already use, and your ServiceNow admins manage it alongside everything else.

See it for yourself: watch Clarity 101.

How to evaluate strategic portfolio management software

  1. Bring finance and resource managers in early. They'll live with the financial and staffing model every day. If IT leadership expects everything to run on ServiceNow, hearing those requirements firsthand saves a debate later.
  2. Demo the hard parts with your own data. Ask each vendor to roll up one of your real programs, run your budget cycle, and staff a project from role requests.
  3. Check what your ServiceNow license covers. SPM is licensed separately from IT service management, and some capabilities are only in the higher SPM Prime package. Ask how business users who plan but don't work tickets are licensed.
  4. Map the connections before you decide. Check how each option works with ServiceNow and with the tools your delivery teams use, such as Rally or Jira.
  5. Plan who supports it after go-live. Decide whether that's your ServiceNow admins, a Clarity admin, or a partner.

You don't have to put everything on one platform

Choosing Clarity doesn't mean leaving ServiceNow. Many organizations keep ServiceNow for service management and use Clarity for portfolio, financial, and resource planning, then connect the two so demand, project status, and changes move between them. ConnectALL handles that integration in ValueOps, and some environments call for a custom integration instead. Connecting your portfolio and delivery tools explains how it works.

Why work with Virelli on Clarity

Virelli is a Broadcom Pinnacle Partner and Broadcom’s 2025 Agile Operations Partner of the Year for North America. Our team has worked with Clarity since 2004, with more than 1,000 implementations behind us.

Many of our Clarity projects include a ServiceNow connection, from universities to federal agencies. Our team regularly builds custom integrations between Clarity and the finance, delivery, and service systems around it, including ERPs like Oracle Financials and tools like Jira.

When you buy Clarity through Virelli, support comes through us too. Our team works your support cases directly and brings in Broadcom when an issue needs to go further, and our managed services team stays involved after go-live. If you want to test Clarity against your own programs first, our rapid prototype gets you a working version in less than a month.

Frequently asked questions

What's the difference between Clarity and ServiceNow SPM?

Both are strategic portfolio management tools. ServiceNow SPM runs on the ServiceNow platform and fits best when portfolio work already flows through ServiceNow, usually IT. Clarity is a dedicated portfolio platform that fits best when portfolios include business-led work, or when programs, staffing, and financials need to roll up across many projects. Many organizations connect the two.

Is ServiceNow Strategic Portfolio Management the same as ITBM?

Yes. ServiceNow renamed IT Business Management (ITBM) to Strategic Portfolio Management (SPM). It covers demand management, project and portfolio management, and related planning tools on the ServiceNow platform. The ITBM name still shows up in older documentation and conversations.

Can Clarity integrate with ServiceNow?

Yes. Clarity is commonly connected to ServiceNow, so demand, project, and change information flows between the two systems. Teams use ConnectALL, the integration layer in ValueOps, or a custom integration, depending on what needs to sync and how often.

Can we move from ServiceNow SPM to Clarity?

Yes. A move usually starts by mapping what you have in ServiceNow, such as projects, resources, and financial plans, to how Clarity will be set up, then cleaning the data and testing it before go-live. ServiceNow can stay in place for service management and connect to Clarity after the move.

Do I need ServiceNow SPM if I already use ServiceNow for IT service management?

Not necessarily. Running ServiceNow for IT service management makes SPM easy to consider, but the right choice depends on who uses the portfolio, how staffing decisions get made, and how delivery teams work. SPM is licensed separately from IT service management, so it's its own decision. Clarity can handle portfolio planning while ServiceNow keeps running service management, with the two connected.

See how Clarity would handle your portfolio

Get a walkthrough of Clarity built around your portfolio, including how it would connect to your ServiceNow setup.

Connect with a Clarity expert

Share this post